Almost every zine reader has picked up at least one issue of Maximum Rock and Roll and I think the best way to describe XD is to compare/contrast the style between the
the two.
The number of zine reviews is much larger in XD because that's its main focus. There are also some "perzine tendencies" with the inclusion of columns and announcements focused on the zine world and also a little info on each of the contributing writers. MRR doesn't include a look into the writers but does include disparate columns on a mishmash of topics and a more review items including music, so that could be positive or negative for many readers. The most important contrast is the agenda in reviewing. Where MRR's reviews are generally jaded and slam the new but praise the established, XD is very informative as to what the zine really contains plus its style. The reviewers also give constructive criticism when it applies and that's important for the zines' creators and help the readers make an informed decision.
Most review zines cater to a certain type such as activist or political, music, personal, etc. but there is a good variety and openness to the submissions and the reviewers. This issue features 20 reviewers and each takes on 5 to 17! Also, some zines are reviewed by different people to give them another view, which is a great idea. So while some are reluctant to spend $3, there are more than enough honest recommendations for all your favorite genres.
I really couldn't find something I didn't like about XD. This is the only publication I can think of where I've seen the agendas of hippies, punks, literary buffs, artists, and everyone in between are seen with open minds. This is a great resource that I'd recommend for those starting to check zines out for the first time and of course anyone that wants to find something new to read.
Issue 14: 60 ? sized
Cost: $3
Address: PO Box 963 . Havre de Grace, MC . 21078
Website: leekinginc.com
Email: davida@leekinginc.com
coming soon: woven six, papercuts and promises
Posted by kubbazine
at 5:46 AM
